Loading

Through the Lives of Black Women, Erica Armstrong Dunbar Tells Fuller Histories of Early America

Enslaved woman Ona Judge made a daring escape from George and Martha Washington’s household in 1796. Now, nearly 250 years later, historian Erica Armstrong Dunbar is telling her story.

Dunbar’s book, “Never Caught: The Washingtons’ Relentless Pursuit of Their Runaway Slave, Ona Judge,” was selected as the Common Experience reading for the incoming Duke Undergraduate Class of 2030. On September 25, 2026, the Duke and Durham community had the opportunity to hear from Dunbar at two events — one at the Nasher Museum of Art, hosted by the Office of Undergraduate Education, and one at the Durham County Main Library, hosted by the Kenan Institute for Ethics as part of its event series, The Ethics of Now.

Two women onstage in front of "Never Caught" flyer
Caption: Dunbar spoke with Duke history professor Tamika Nunley at the on-campus event at the Nasher. Photo credit: Gabrielle Stanfield.

As part of We the People: A Duke and Durham Initiative, an ongoing commemoration of the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, these events offered attendees the chance to think about the nation’s evolving identity through its early history. At the Nasher event, Dunbar pointed out that Ona Judge is a key person to consider when we are reflecting on the meaning of liberty — both then and now.

Similarly, in her opening comments at the Durham County Main Library, Ethics of Now host and Duke history professor Adriane Lentz-Smith said that hundreds of years after Ona Judge escaped from slavery, “we are still reckoning with what it means to be free.”

Dunbar said she first came across Ona Judge’s story while combing through digital historical archives, where she discovered a runaway slave advertisement placed by the Washingtons after Judge fled their household in 1796. The Washingtons made several attempts to return her to their custody but were ultimately unsuccessful, and Judge lived the rest of her life as a fugitive in New Hampshire.

Dunbar recognized how Judge’s story could offer historians a different entry point to the Washingtons’ story. Historical accounts and narratives are often laser-focused on the Founding Fathers — a phenomenon Dunbar refers to as “founder chic.” But as a person who lived with the Washingtons during their years as the first “First Family,” and who experienced life as both an enslaved person and as a provisionally free one, Ona Judge’s story offers a unique historical perspective into the United States in its earliest years as a nation.

Dunbar was honest about the challenges of researching Judge’s life. Ona Judge did not make it into the historical archives in the same way that George Washington did — and, as an absconded slave, she did her best to lie low. 

“An enslaved woman who spent 50 years in hiding is hard to find in records,” Dunbar said.

While Judge did give interviews to abolitionist newsletters later in her life, Dunbar had to make several inferences while writing her book, drawing from her extensive research into the lives of Black women during the same period.

“None of the speculation I did was fictional,” Dunbar told the audience. “It was based on the experiences of other Black women who were either fugitive or enslaved or free who lived in the same space and time as Ona.”

Two women speak onstage
In conversation with Duke historian Adriane Lentz-Smith (right), Erica Armstrong Dunbar spoke about her book “Never Caught” at the Durham County Main Library on September 25, 2026.

In the years following the publication of her book on Judge, Dunbar became involved in the production of the award-winning HBO show “The Gilded Age.” Originally hired as a historical consultant to help the show tell more historically accurate stories about Black women during the 19th century, she was later elevated to co-executive producer by showrunner Julian Fellowes.

“Sunday nights at 9 p.m. are my biggest classroom,” Dunbar said, pointing out that she is able to share her historical research with an audience of millions through “The Gilded Age.” Though she was originally worried people would think she had “sold out” or “gone Hollywood,” Dunbar says she now hopes that other historians will find ways to be creative without worrying about sacrificing their respectability or image in the field.

When offering advice to up-and-coming historians, especially Black historians, Dunbar recommended a thick skin and an open mind. She said that following your passion and honing your craft is the best way to keep your head up when telling underrepresented stories, especially ones that draw challenges.

Despite “Never Caught” receiving wide acclaim — it was named a National Book Award Finalist for Nonfiction in 2017 and received the Frederick Douglass Book Award in 2018 — the work of commemorating Ona Judge is far from over. While Judge’s story was once included in an exhibit at the President’s House in Philadelphia, the National Parks Service removed the panels in 2026 as part of the Trump administration’s campaign against “negative” representations of the nation at historic sites. The community pushed back, painting murals and playing videos on mobile trucks to keep Judge’s story visible.

Dunbar’s work reminds us that the stories we tell about the past remain unfinished, and that every generation engages with history in different ways in order to better understand the present.

Part of commemoration is aspirational, Dunbar said. In other words, the stories we tell reflect the nation we want to become.

Two women pose holding up a book
Dunbar poses with a fan at the book signing following the event at the Durham County Main Library. Photo credit: Lei He.

This story was written by Reese Ritter in collaboration with Sarah Rogers. Arka Kapadia Solanki and Catherine Angst contributed reporting.